The left-handed power bat the Chicago Cubs long wished for finally arrived. The 24-year-old right fielder belted 20 homers his rookie season. His .316 on-base percentage left something to be desired, but power has a way of easing developmental worries.
That was 2010 and Tyler Colvin was full of promise. The 2011 season would be the year the 2006 first-rounder would cement his big league status….oops.
In 206 at-bats, Colvin batted .150. His .204 on-base percentage barely surpassed the Mendoza Line. In 35 at-bats against lefties, he recorded two hits. He found reprieve against righties, posting a .170 batting average. His 58 strikeouts are not shocking, considering the 100 Ks he tallied his rookie year. He hit six home runs, but his anemic batting average left management with no choice but to bench him.
The Colorado Rockies had their own Tyler Colvin. The 10th pick of the 2003 MLB Draft, Ian Stewart never realized the promise Colorado management saw in him as a senior at La Quinta High School in California. In 2009 as a 24-year-old, Stewart blasted 25 home runs while batting .228. In 2010 he improved to .256 with 18 home runs. However, right when things looked good, Stewart collapsed in 2011. He batted .156 in 122 at-bats without a single home run— in Colorado.
Newly named President of Baseball Operations Theo Epstein saw two players in need of a location change. On December 8, 2011, the Cubs sent Colvin and second baseman DJ LeMahieu to Colorado for Stewart and pitcher Casey Weathers (another failed first-rounder).
Colorado fit Colvin well. The 26-year-old currently owns a .290/.329/.551 line. Seven of his 14 home runs left road ballparks. In 62 at-bats against leftied, he is batting .274. His 1.3 oWAR matches his 2010 number. His eight triples and seven steals are career-highs. He is on pace to set career-highs in doubles, RBIs and batting average. He is benefiting from playing in Coors Field, but he is a .272 batter on the road this year.
While the trade reinvigorated Colvin’s career, the same cannot be said for Stewart. The Chicago Cubs Opening Day third baseman, Stewart was hitting .201 with five home runs in 55 games before landing on the 60-day disabled list with a wrist injury.
Baseball can be a mental game. Some players find a change of scenery the difference between success and failure. In other cases, the game beats you. The league learns your holes and the ball is always one step ahead, no matter what park you call home.
The Big Guy